Greetings
I'm not sure if anyone is still around on this board (it's been a few months since anyone has posted), but I thought I would check.
I want to start with a big Thank You to everyone for making this forum & posting. I'm recently begun exploring the CR world, and have been called to explore a Welsh path. Having this board as a resource, to explore past topics, & to have ideas to draw from as I start to create my own ritual is... huge.
In addition to my 'hello', and as a way of introducing myself, I would like to ask your opinions on a few aspects of Welsh tradition & belief that I've been getting hung-up on. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
- The Tylwyth Teg. Much of the folk-lore I've come across has been directed towards the Tylwyth, and I'm trying to figure out where they would have belonged in traditional (pre-christian) Welsh Celtic belief. These are the two main hypotheses I'm entertaining, let me know which one you think is more right, or if there are completely different ways you've interpreted things.
1. The Tylwyth have always been a part of Welsh belief. Pre-christian influence, a typical Welshman or Welshwoman would have recognized the existence of the Tylwyth in addition to general and local deities, etc. Perhaps later Christian influence discouraged folklore and beliefs in other deities while maybe being more willing to humor stories about the Folk, which is why most of the folklore (or maybe just most of what I've encountered?) deals primarily or only with the Tylwyth and not other deities as such.
2. Belief in the Tylwyth Teg has replaced belief in deities as a result of Christian influence. The literally larger-than-life deities have been literally & figuratively shrunk into the stature of the Tylwyth. The only way traditional beliefs could survive was to be re-shaped in a guise more amenable to the ruling civilization.
At the end of the day, I'm guessing that there is no definite answer. I'm mostly curious because it shapes how I view customs the Tylwyth; are these beings in and of themselves to be respected, or are the related lore to be taken to be more descriptive of the original Welsh deities?
-I'm starting to be overwhelmed with the amount of opinions pertaining to Welsh folklore. I think that there's a couple (maybe more than a couple) conversations to be had here, but to start I'll keep it simple: What, if any, has been your experience with the authors John Rhys and Marie Trevelyan? Is their research accurate, etc? I've read a good bit of J. Rhys, & he seems really good, BUT... I have very little to compare it to. I'm a bit more wary of M. Trevelyan because she so rarely cites her sources (and, one of her few is Iolo), but there's a lot in her 'Folklore & Folk-Stories' that would be really cool to use as a base... if it's credible.
I'll leave it here for now. Even if no-one is here to read this, it was a good exercise to write it out & have a chance to be more precise in my thinking, so thanks :)
I hope to hear from you (all) soon, and, Greetings!
Regards,
-Tony-
P.S. I know that this is all more research-oriented. Welsh CR for me does have a spiritual side (that's kind of the point that all this research is supposed to supplement), but I thought some of the 'dryer' stuff would be a good place to start.
P.P.S. I haven't looked through much of the archives yet. If I'm asking questions that have been discussed umpteen times before, my apologies. I was too excited to introduce myself to bother much with patience.
geeky
ill
okay
content